The Hero Assumption: How Elite Leaders Unlock Team Potential and Drive Measurable Results

In today’s volatile business environment, CEOs and senior executives face unprecedented challenges in talent management. With record-high turnover rates and persistent workforce disengagement, organizations struggle to retain their top performers. This talent crisis directly impacts the bottom line. It costs from one-half to two times an employee’s annual salary to replace them, and lost productivity costs U.S. businesses an estimated $1.8 trillion annually.

As the CEO of my own company and a leadership consultant who has worked with Fortune 500 companies across multiple industries, I’ve both observed and personally experienced how the right leadership approach transforms organizational performance. In my company, we drink our own champagne, teaching the whole team the principles of leader approachability – a scientifically validated approach to leadership that revolutionized our culture and dramatically improved our results.

The Costly Leadership Blind Spot

Most executives understand the importance of company culture, but many underestimate how directly their personal leadership approach influences retention and performance. Extensive research conducted by Gallup reveals that frontline leaders account for 70% of the variance in team engagement scores.

When executives make even subtle negative assumptions about their team members’ capabilities, they trigger what psychologists call the “nocebo effect” – a negative self-fulfilling prophecy. This unconscious leadership blind spot manifests in micromanagement, lack of delegation, and limited growth opportunities that drive top talent away.

I experienced this firsthand in my own company. As I share in my recently published The Leader-Shift Playbook, despite developing leadership frameworks that helped other organizations thrive, our own culture was stagnant. Everything funneled through me, creating bottlenecks and frustration. We hit a plateau with no growth for four consecutive years. It wasn’t until I recognized how my own leadership assumptions were creating dysfunction that we began to transform.

The Four Shifts That Transform Leadership Effectiveness

Our turnaround began when we implemented four fundamental mindset shifts that have since proven effective across multiple organizations:

1. Shifting Your Belief in Your Impact
   The Challenge: Most leaders dramatically underestimate their day-to-day influence on team behavior and culture.
   The Solution: Elite executives deliberately track their impact by monitoring the effects of their words, actions, and expectations on team performance metrics.
   Real-World Application: In my company, we began regular quarterly discussions where my leadership team would give me direct feedback on how my behavior affected their performance. This uncomfortable but crucial practice revealed that my tendency to chase “shiny objects” was diverting resources and creating confusion. By acknowledging this impact and adjusting my behavior, we increased focus and execution across the organization.
2. Shifting From Unconscious Bias to Disciplined Perception
   The Challenge: Research from Harvard psychologists Banaji and Greenwald reveals that up to 90% of leadership decisions happen at an unconscious level, often reinforcing existing biases.
   The Solution: Elite executives implement structured perception protocols that interrupt automatic judgments and challenge initial assumptions.
   Real-World Application: We teach leaders to use the “Walk a Mile” tool. This simple framework helps leaders document observable facts separate from interpretations, consider multiple explanations for behavior, and validate understanding through direct dialogue.
   Personally, this shift transformed how we handle performance issues. Before, I often made the “Villain Assumption” about underperforming team members. After implementing this shift, we began uncovering root causes that were often quite different from our initial judgments, leading to more effective interventions and dramatic performance improvements.
3. Shift From Fixed Mindset to Growth Acceleration
   The Challenge: Leaders often make rapid, fixed judgments about team members’ capabilities that become self-fulfilling prophecies.
   The Solution: Elite executives adopt what Stanford psychologist Carol Dweck calls a “growth mindset,” using a structured approach to accurately diagnose performance gaps.
   Real-World Application: In our own company, we began using the Skill-Awareness-Values (SAV) diagnostic framework to precisely identify whether performance issues stemmed from skill gaps, awareness gaps, or values misalignment.
   This approach allowed us to take a team member who had been in the same data entry role for 13 years and successfully transition her to a completely different position requiring substantial new skills. By believing in her capacity to grow (despite her own initial doubts) and providing targeted support, she became a standout performer who now leads an organization that was recently honored with a Congressional Gold Medal.
4. Shifting From Power Distance to Leveraging Your Relationships
   The Challenge: Research from Google’s Project Aristotle identified psychological safety as the #1 predictor of team performance, yet power dynamics often undermine this critical factor.
   The Solution: Elite executives strategically leverage vulnerability and targeted questions to dismantle barriers and access unfiltered organizational intelligence.
   Real-World Application: This shift began in our company with what we now call “Connection Conversations.” These structured dialogues address three questions employees desperately want answered but never ask:
   “Do you like me?”,
   “Do you think I have what it takes?”, and
   “Am I worth the effort?”
   By creating psychological safety through vulnerability and strategic questioning, we uncovered critical organizational blindspots and accessed intelligence that had previously been filtered out. Our quarterly conversations now systematically build connection while uncovering operational insights that drive continuous improvement.

Measuring the ROI of Leadership Shifts

Organizations that systematically implement these four shifts achieve measurable performance improvements. In 2021 Josh Royes, PhD and I published research based on a sample of 7,728 employees in companies across multiple industries. We found that employees who rate their supervisor as approachable have:

• 75% lower turnover intention.
• 77.5% more likelihood to engage in discretionary effort and organizational citizenship.
• 78% higher organization satisfaction.

In our own company, these shifts ended our four-year plateau and transformed our culture. We’ve never been stronger in our forty-seven year history, with both culture and performance metrics reaching all-time highs.

The Competitive Advantage of Belief

The most powerful tool for unleashing organizational potential isn’t a new technology platform or management system—it’s the fundamental belief leaders have in their teams. This belief becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, creating the conditions for exceptional performance.

What makes the Hero Assumption so powerful is that it isn’t just a leadership philosophy; it’s a strategic business advantage with measurable ROI. When teams feel genuinely believed in, they consistently outperform expectations and remain loyal even in competitive labor markets.

The transformation begins with a simple but profound choice: Will you see your team members as the heroes of their own stories—people with the desire and capacity to excel—or will you unconsciously cast them as supporting characters in your organizational narrative?

My experience as both a CEO and consultant has convinced me that when leaders make the Hero Assumption, they unlock levels of performance and engagement that conventional management approaches simply cannot achieve.

Written by Phillip B. Wilson.
Have you read?
World’s Safest & Most Dangerous Countries For Travelers.
Longest and Shortest Life Expectancies in the World.
World’s Most And Least Stressed Countries.
Best cities in the world.
Largest Economies in the World by GDP (PPP).