The 3 Secret Ingredients for Making Big Bet Decisions

Not all big-bet decisions can make or break your organisation, but they are, by definition, significant. They are not for the faint of heart, but they’re essential for driving growth and staying ahead in today’s competitive landscape. So, what separates the visionaries from the also-rans? The answer lies in three secret ingredients that, when combined, create a recipe for success.

1. Mental Models: The Foundation of Strategic Thinking
   Imagine having a Swiss Army knife for your mind. That’s exactly what mental models provide. These cognitive frameworks help us make sense of complex situations and guide our decision making process. But it’s not just about having a toolbox of mental models; it’s about weaving them into compelling narratives.

   Why narratives matter: Our brains are wired for stories. When we frame our big bet decisions within a narrative structure, we tap into a powerful cognitive process that helps us:

   – Organise information more effectively.
   – Identify potential obstacles and opportunities.
   – Communicate our vision to stakeholders.

   By turning mental models into narratives, you can create a robust foundation for big bet decisions, ensuring they’re not just shots in the dark but calculated moves based on a deep understanding of the business landscape.

2. Meshing Narratives: Uncovering Hidden Patterns across the Business Landscape
   Here’s where you find the diamonds. The real magic happens when you start meshing different narratives together. This process creates a tapestry of insights, where each thread represents a different perspective. Here is an example using customers.

   When it comes to customer behaviour, meshing narratives can reveal patterns that might otherwise remain hidden. For example:

   – Combining customer feedback with sales data narratives.
   – Overlaying market trend and product development narratives.
   – Integrating narratives of your competitors’ strategies with your narrative for your innovation pipeline.

   By weaving these narratives together, you and your team can identify emerging patterns and trends that inform your big bet decisions. It’s like having a crystal ball that shows you not just what customers are doing now, but what they’re likely to do in the future.

3. Risk vs. Opportunity: The Balancing Act of Big Bets
   Every big bet comes with its share of risks and opportunities that need to be navigated according to your appetite for risk. Here’s how successful CEOs approach this balancing act:

   – Quantify the downside: What’s the worst-case scenario, and can your company weather that storm? Or do you not have a choice?
   – Envision the upside: If things go well, it’s not just about the direct outcomes, imagine how transformative this decision could be for your business?
   – Consider the opportunity cost: What are you giving up by not making this big bet?
   – Align stakeholder appetite for risk: Your appetite for risk and that of your board, team and key suppliers will not be exactly the same. You need to ensure these key players are sufficiently aligned otherwise you will meet roadblocks or will be needing to lasso people into line.

   By methodically evaluating both risk and opportunity, you can make big bet decisions with confidence, knowing they’ve considered all angles.

The Secret Sauce in Action: A Real-World Example

Let’s look at how these three ingredients came together in a real-world scenario. In 2006, Netflix made a big bet on streaming video, despite having a successful DVD-by-mail business.

• Mental Models and Narratives: Netflix CEO Reed Hastings used the mental model of technological disruption to craft a narrative about the future of entertainment consumption.
• Meshing Narratives: By combining stories about broadband adoption, changing consumer habits, and the rise of mobile devices, Netflix identified a pattern pointing towards on-demand streaming as the future.
• Assessing Risk vs. Opportunity: The risk was cannibalising their existing business and investing in unproven technology. The opportunity was becoming a pioneer in a potentially massive new market.

The result? Netflix transformed from a DVD rental company to a global streaming giant and content powerhouse, demonstrating the power of making the right big bet at the right time.

As a CEO, you’re in a unique position to leverage these secret ingredients for your own big bet decisions. By mastering these three elements, you’ll be well-equipped to make big bet decisions that can propel your company to new heights. The question is, what will your next big bet be?

Written by Bryan Whitefield.
Have you read?
The Gentle Art of Conversation Leaders Need to Master.
Why Real Leaders Don’t Need a Title.
To self-reflect or not to self-reflect: How to overcome the complexities of self-awareness.
Tipping the Scaling for Net-Zero Success.
Achieving Leadership Brilliance with Cut, Clarity, Color, and Carat.