The Great Smartphone Debate in Europe: Are Bans in Schools the Answer?

The conversation surrounding smartphone restrictions for children and teenagers continues to stir debate across Europe. While some countries have implemented outright bans in schools, others are grappling with how to balance technology’s benefits with its potential distractions. A UNESCO report from 2023 advocated for the limited use of smartphones in classrooms, strictly for learning purposes, and found that over 60 nations have taken steps to address this issue.

Studies have shown that smartphones can be both a helpful educational tool and a source of disruption. Ben Carter, a medical statistics professor at King’s College London, explained that while smartphones are often used for assignments and teaching aids, they can lead to distractions, especially when notifications interrupt tasks. Carter described the evidence on the effectiveness of bans as mixed, suggesting that more research is needed before reaching definitive conclusions.

European Nations Taking Action

France

France was among the first to take decisive steps, banning phones in primary and secondary schools in 2018. This year, an extended trial of a “digital break” was introduced in nearly 200 schools, impacting 50,000 students and reinforcing the earlier law.

United Kingdom

In the UK, a proposed bill aims to address children’s addictive phone habits, with discussions ongoing about banning phones in schools. While the government has not confirmed plans for a nationwide school ban, a 2023 survey revealed strong public support, with 70% of respondents advocating for restricting phones during lessons.

Netherlands

A ban on the non-educational use of smartphones came into effect in Dutch primary and secondary schools in January 2023. The measure extends to smartwatches and tablets but allows exceptions for students with disabilities or special needs.

Italy

Italy prohibits mobile phone use in classrooms from pre-school through secondary school, except when needed for individualised learning or disability support.

Hungary

Hungary introduced a nationwide phone ban in schools starting September 2024. The policy faced backlash, with some teachers labelling it outdated.

Spain

Spain’s education ministry is working on a unified national policy for mobile phone use in schools, building on existing regional bans. Currently, around seven regions have restrictions in place.

Ireland

Ireland is investing €9 million to implement a nationwide phone ban. Lockable storage solutions will soon be rolled out across schools, ensuring consistency in enforcing a no-phone policy.

Sweden

Sweden prohibits phones in classrooms unless they are part of the learning process. The government has also issued guidance recommending limited screen time for children.

Belgium

Starting in the 2025/2026 school year, Belgium’s Wallonia-Brussels Federation will ban recreational use of phones in schools to enhance focus and foster a healthier learning environment.

Greece

In Greece, students are now required to store their phones in their bags during the school day. Prime Minister Kyriákos Mitsotákis stressed the importance of this policy, citing evidence of phones causing distractions in class.

Latvia

Latvia’s parliament has approved a measure banning phone use for students up to grade six starting May 2025, with exceptions for educational purposes.

Luxembourg

From Easter 2025, smartphones will be banned in Luxembourg’s primary schools. High schools will enforce stricter policies to ensure minimal phone use during classes.

Finland

The Finnish government plans to amend legislation, granting schools greater authority to limit phone use to educational or health-related purposes only.

Some European countries, including Denmark, Cyprus, Bulgaria, and Portugal, are considering similar restrictions. While studies like the OECD’s PISA 2022 report indicate that phone bans can reduce classroom distractions, enforcement remains a challenge. Nearly 30% of students in schools with bans reported using their phones regularly during the school day.

Experts, including Carter, stress the importance of creating balanced policies that address both the drawbacks and advantages of technology in education. He argued that bans might not work unless viable alternatives for educational purposes are provided.

As Europe continues to experiment with smartphone policies in schools, the debate highlights the broader challenge of integrating technology responsibly into young people’s lives.

Have you read?
Best Fashion Schools.
Best Universities.
Best Medical Schools.
Best International High Schools.
Countries: Most Female Billionaires.