CEOWORLD magazine

5th Avenue, New York, NY 10001, United States
Phone: +1 3479835101
Email: info@ceoworld.biz
+1 (646) 466-6530 info@ceoworld.biz
Monday, November 16th, 2026 5:58 PM
Home » Global CEO Forum » The answer to AI guardrails? Experience
Global CEO Forum

The answer to AI guardrails? Experience

Victoria Tomlinson

Every board is talking about AI guardrails. We need governance, oversight and humans in the loop. We need people who can spot when AI has got something wrong, recognise bias and understand when an apparently plausible answer could create a very real problem.

But who exactly are these humans in the loop?

Because at the same time as organisations are investing heavily in AI, many are still allowing some of their most experienced people to leave.

I think we are missing something important.

One of the best guardrails we have for AI could be sitting in our organisations already. It is experience.

AI can produce an answer. Someone has to know when it is wrong 

AI is extraordinarily good at processing information, identifying patterns and producing apparently authoritative answers at speed. What it does not have is decades of lived experience of what happens next.

An experienced finance director has seen what happens when apparently sensible assumptions turn out to be wrong. A senior lawyer has encountered the unusual case that does not fit neatly into the precedent. An experienced HR director knows that a perfectly logical restructuring plan can have completely unexpected human consequences. A communications director who has lived through a crisis may spot the one sentence in an AI-generated announcement that could inflame the situation.

They may not always be able to explain immediately why something feels wrong. They have simply seen enough over 30 or 40 years to recognise the warning signs.

That is judgement.

And far from becoming less valuable in the age of AI, I believe it is becoming more valuable.

When AI needs human judgement

Klarna provides a salutary example.

In February 2024, the fintech company announced that its AI chatbot was doing the work of 700 customer-service agents. By December, CEO Sebastian Siemiatkowski was saying that AI could do all the jobs that humans do.

But by mid-2025, the company was recruiting customer-service staff again. Customers had complained about generic and repetitive responses and Siemiatkowski acknowledged that Klarna had gone too far in prioritising cost over quality.

The lesson is not that Klarna was wrong to use AI. It is that efficiency is not the same as effectiveness.

Customer service is exactly the sort of area where human judgement matters. A customer may be angry, worried or dealing with circumstances that do not fit neatly into a standard response. An experienced person can pick up nuance, understand what is really being said and recognise when an apparently straightforward problem is anything but.

AI can deal brilliantly with routine enquiries. The judgement is knowing when the situation is no longer routine.

And that applies far beyond customer service.

Lloyds took a different approach 

When my co-author, Louise Ballard, founder of Atheni.ai, spoke to Lloyds Banking Group, it provided a very different case study.

Rather than assuming new technology belongs to the young, it invested heavily in its senior leaders’ AI capability before rolling out company-wide.

Its top 13 executives visited Silicon Valley and Canada to understand what was happening and what it could mean for the bank. Senior leaders then had around 18 months to develop their understanding and strategies for their own areas.

By October 2025, more than 110 senior executives had completed around 80 hours of learning over six months through Lloyds’ bespoke Leading with AI programme.

If AI is going to transform an organisation, senior leaders cannot delegate their understanding of it to younger or more technically confident colleagues. They need enough knowledge to ask the right questions, challenge assumptions and understand the consequences of the decisions being made.

As Lloyds’ Sharon Doherty points out, some 50-year-olds are more tech-savvy than some 20-year-olds. It’s much more about mindset – whether someone is open, curious and prepared to try new things.

What experienced leaders bring is something different. They know the organisation, its customers and its history. They have seen strategies succeed and fail. They have dealt with crises and unintended consequences. Combine that experience with a good understanding of AI and you have something extremely powerful.

This is what businesses should be aiming for. Not AI instead of experience, nor experience resisting AI, but experienced people learning to use AI and bringing their judgement to it.

But businesses are throwing away the very skills they need 

For years, we have treated career progression as a pyramid. People build expertise, reach senior positions and then at some arbitrary point in their 50s or 60s we start talking about succession and retirement.

Meanwhile, people increasingly are leading active, productive – even demanding – lives, well into their 80s and 90s. And sometimes 100s. Look at Sir David Attenborough and June Spencer who played a key character in the radio soap, The Archers, until she was 103.

So employees could easily be looking at another 20 or 30 years of productive life after the point at which traditional careers currently start pushing people towards the exit.

That was already wasteful. AI makes it potentially dangerous.

If organisations need people capable of challenging AI outputs, understanding context and exercising judgement, why would they deliberately discard people with decades of accumulated knowledge?

This does not mean keeping everyone in the same senior job indefinitely. Quite the opposite.

We need to rethink what later working life looks like.

An experienced executive may not want another ten years of running a division. They might work three days a week, lead projects, advise younger teams, mentor founders, support clients or become part of an internal AI oversight group.

We need imagination rather than a retirement date.

And who develops the next generation’s judgement? 

There is another reason why this matters.

AI is increasingly taking over the routine early-career work through which previous generations learned their professions.

Junior lawyers learned by researching cases and drafting documents. Accountants worked through accounts. Young consultants gathered information and analysed it. People learned not just through formal training but by doing the work, getting things wrong and watching experienced colleagues deal with situations they had never encountered before.

If AI does more of that work, how will the next generation acquire the experience needed eventually to challenge it?

We could end up with an extraordinary paradox.

We remove experienced people from organisations because we assume their skills are outdated. We automate the junior work through which younger people traditionally acquired experience. Then we discover that we desperately need human judgement to oversee the technology.

That is not an AI problem. It is a workforce planning problem.

Experience needs to travel both ways 

Since starting Next-Up, we have walked the talk on all this, bringing experienced people together with tech entrepreneurs and founders.

Initially, there was often nervousness on both sides. The experienced executives would say, “But I know nothing about tech.”

My answer was simple. You don’t need to. They know about the tech.

What they may not have experienced is the moment when the relationship between two founders has run its course. Or a cash-flow crisis. Or a major customer threatening to leave. Or expanding too quickly. Or hiring the wrong senior person. Or handling a board when things are going badly.

Someone who has spent decades in business may recognise these situations almost immediately because they have encountered versions of them before.

And it works the other way too. The entrepreneur understands technology, new markets and different ways of working. Put the two together and both learn.

Knowledge travels both ways.

That is surely what we should be trying to create inside organisations as AI transforms work: not a battle between the generations over who understands the future, but teams in which technological fluency and accumulated human judgement sit alongside each other.

Experience is not infallibility 

Of course, being 60 does not automatically confer wisdom and being 25 does not mean someone lacks judgement.

Experienced people have biases too. They can be wrong. They need to understand AI and learn how to use it. And younger colleagues may spot assumptions and risks that people who have spent decades in an industry no longer see.

This is why age diversity matters.

Good decisions rarely come from everyone around a table having the same experience and assumptions. We have understood this increasingly around gender and ethnicity. We have barely begun to think about it in relation to age.

People in their 50s, 60s, 70s and more are perfectly capable of learning new technology. AI can actually be enormously liberating because you no longer need years of technical training to use sophisticated tools.

The question is whether organisations give experienced employees access to those tools and encourage them to experiment with them.

What should CEOs do now? 

First, look at who is leaving your organisation.

Not just by broad age bands. Look at recruitment, promotion, redundancy and departure data by decade. How many people in their 50s are you recruiting? How many in their 60s? And you need to start thinking even about people in their 80s and 90s. Long before that, what happens to people as they approach traditional retirement ages?

Then look at what knowledge is leaving with them.

Who understands why a particular customer relationship works? Who remembers the last three crises? Who knows why a process exists in the first place? Who has made the mistakes that your AI system has not yet encountered?

Next, look at your AI governance.

When your policy says there must be a “human in the loop”, ask who that human is.

Do they have sufficient experience to challenge the answer rather than simply approve it? Do they understand the wider context? Do they have the authority to say no?

And finally, create deliberate opportunities for generations to work together.

Do not put your experienced employees in a corner and ask them to “mentor the young”. Give generations real problems to solve together. Let younger employees bring their understanding of emerging technology and new behaviours. Let experienced colleagues bring context, pattern recognition, relationships and judgement.

Both sides will learn.

The future of work should be ageless 

We have spent years talking about AI replacing human skills. I think we are beginning to understand that the more powerful AI becomes, the more important distinctly human capabilities become.

Judgement. Context. Creativity. Curiosity. Empathy. The ability to challenge an answer that looks perfectly convincing.

And experience.

The organisations that succeed with AI will not necessarily be those with the youngest workforces or even those that automate fastest. They will be those that understand what technology does brilliantly, what humans do differently and how to combine the two.

Before we allow another generation of experience to walk out of the door, perhaps we should ask whether we have just found one of the most important jobs for it.

Written by Victoria Tomlinson.

Have you read?
Vanuatu Citizenship-by-Investment Program. Best Golden Visa and Residency-by-Investment Programs in the World.
Australia National Innovation Visa Program. Austria Private Residence Program. Bulgaria Residency-by-Investment Program.

Share this article:
Follow CEOWORLD Magazine on Google News

Follow CEOWORLD Magazine on: Google News, LinkedIn, X (Twitter), and Facebook.

Note: The views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of CEOWORLD Magazine, its Editorial Board, or management. Content is provided "as is," may contain monetized links, and is not professional advice. See our Ethics & Guidelines for details. Reproduction requires prior written permission.

Contact info@ceoworld.biz for inquiries or media requests.

Victoria Tomlinson
Victoria Tomlinson is founder and CEO of Next-Up, helping employers and professional firms realise the value of employee experience before and after retirement. She is co-author with AI expert Louise Ballard of Expiry Date Never: Age is the New Superpower (Pearson, £14.99) and on the advisory board of WILD… Read Victoria Tomlinson’s full executive profile here →