CEOWORLD magazine

5th Avenue, New York, NY 10001, United States
Phone: +1 3479835101
Email: info@ceoworld.biz
+1 (646) 466-6530 info@ceoworld.biz
Monday, November 16th, 2026 12:53 PM
Home » Executive Council » We Ask Leaders to Be Courageous. Then We Reward Them for Being Safe
Executive Council

We Ask Leaders to Be Courageous. Then We Reward Them for Being Safe

Mathias Goyen, M.D.

In 1989, during three months of basic military training, I served under a sergeant whose name means nothing to anyone reading this. Thirty-seven years later, he remains one of the most remarkable leaders I have ever encountered. I have spent the decades since in medicine, academia, and large organizations, working with accomplished people carrying far more impressive titles, yet only a handful have created anything approaching the same instinct to follow.

There is an obvious objection to this comparison. In the military, following orders is not optional, and hierarchy carries an authority that corporate leaders neither possess nor should possess. But obedience was never what made this man remarkable. We followed his orders because we had to. We would have followed him outside that system because we wanted to. Thirty-seven years later, I still consider this distinction essential to understanding what leadership really means.

What made him exceptional had little to do with what we usually associate with leadership. He did not talk about leadership or try to inspire us with purpose, values, or carefully chosen words. What we knew was simpler and considerably more powerful: he would never ask us to do something he was unwilling to do himself, he would stand in front of us when responsibility had to be taken rather than behind us when blame had to be assigned, and we never doubted that he regarded responsibility for his people as part of the job rather than an inconvenience created by it.

I do not tell this story because I believe leadership was better in the past, nor because I think the military offers a model corporations should imitate. It does not. I tell it because the memory has increasingly made me wonder why an experience of leadership that felt so immediate then has become so difficult to encounter since.

The easy answer would be that modern organizations simply have too few courageous leaders. I do not believe that. I have worked with many intelligent, decent, and deeply committed people who genuinely wanted to lead well, and I have seen how difficult the organizations around them can make that aspiration to fulfill. The problem may therefore be less about the quality of the people who become leaders than about the conditions under which we ask them to lead.

Modern corporations say they want courage, authenticity, trust, and purpose, and enormous industries have developed around teaching precisely these qualities. Leadership academies, executive coaching, competency models, 360-degree assessments, and succession programs all reflect a genuine desire to create better leaders. Yet the same organizations surround senior executives with another set of expectations that are considerably more immediate: deliver the numbers, explain the forecast, manage the budget, satisfy governance, align stakeholders, minimize risk, retain talent, and make sure nobody above you is unpleasantly surprised.

There is nothing unreasonable about these expectations. Large organizations could not function without them. The problem emerges in their accumulation. Each additional responsibility consumes attention, creates accountability, and introduces another constituency whose interests must be considered, until leadership remains one of the most frequently discussed responsibilities of senior executives while becoming one of the easiest to postpone.

Organizations do not prevent leaders from leading. They simply make so many other things more immediately consequential that leadership becomes what happens if there is time left.

This may explain one of the great contradictions of modern corporate life. We ask leaders to be courageous, then construct careers that reward them for being safe. We celebrate people who challenge assumptions, speak uncomfortable truths, and take responsibility, while promotion systems favor those who deliver predictable results, manage stakeholders successfully, avoid unnecessary disruption, and demonstrate that elusive quality known as being a “safe pair of hands.” None of this requires hypocrisy. It requires rational people responding rationally to the systems in which they work.

The behaviors required to rise through a large organization may become incompatible with some of those we most admire once someone reaches the top. A successful executive learns to read the organization, understand political boundaries, build coalitions, manage risk, and recognize which battles are worth fighting. These are essential organizational skills. Yet practiced over twenty or thirty years, they may also teach a subtler lesson: when to remain silent, when to compromise, when to seek additional alignment before taking a position, and when a principle is important but not quite important enough to spend political capital on.

The problem is not that corporations lack talented people. It is that the behaviors required to rise through them may train some of the qualities we most admire in leaders out of them.

Perhaps the defining difficulty of corporate leadership is therefore not a lack of courage, but an excess of competing loyalties. A senior leader is accountable to employees and customers, but also to a manager, a board, financial targets, governance requirements, investors, and an organization whose expectations do not always point in the same direction. Somewhere within that network sits another loyalty that leadership literature rarely discusses openly: the entirely human desire to preserve one’s own position, reputation, and future.

There is nothing shameful about this. A career built over decades represents more than status. It carries financial obligations, professional identity, family considerations, and the accumulated investment of a significant part of a person’s life. Asking leaders to behave as though none of this matters whenever courage is required is not a serious theory of leadership. It is a romantic one.

The difficulty arises when these loyalties collide. Supporting an employee is easy when doing so carries no personal cost. Speaking truth to power is admirable when power agrees. Challenging a decision is straightforward until the decision belongs to the person who determines your next role. Taking responsibility sounds uncomplicated until failure has consequences that might be avoided by demonstrating that the correct process was followed. It is at precisely these moments that leadership becomes visible.

Yet these are also the moments corporate systems find hardest to recognize. Revenue, margin, forecast accuracy, productivity, and execution against strategic priorities can all be measured and reviewed with remarkable precision. Organizations have become extraordinarily sophisticated at knowing whether executives deliver what was expected of them. What they cannot measure nearly as easily is whether people would choose to follow those executives if the hierarchy disappeared.

No dashboard records the moment a leader absorbs pressure from above rather than transmitting it downward. There is no quarterly metric for standing beside an employee when doing so becomes politically inconvenient, for saying “this was my decision” when something goes wrong, or for giving someone else the credit when it goes right. A performance system struggles to recognize the leader who tells a superior something that needs to be heard despite knowing that silence would be safer.

Some of the behaviors that generate the deepest trust may therefore be among the least visible to the organization itself. They occur in conversations that never reach a dashboard, in decisions whose alternatives will never be known, and in moments when a leader spends political capital without receiving anything measurable in return. Employees remember them. Organizations often do not.

Perhaps this is why leadership has become so easy to talk about and so difficult to recognize. We have developed an extraordinarily sophisticated vocabulary around it: authenticity, empowerment, vulnerability, purpose, psychological safety, servant leadership, transformational leadership. Many of these concepts describe something important. But language can create the illusion that because we have become better at describing leadership, we have become better at producing it.

Leadership does not become real because an organization has defined its behaviors. It becomes real when one of those behaviors becomes expensive.

Courage that carries no risk is simply agreement. Accountability without consequences is a statement of values. Loyalty that survives only while interests remain aligned is a transaction. The qualities we most admire in leaders acquire their meaning when exercising them becomes personally inconvenient.

This is where my memory of that sergeant from 1989 becomes relevant again. I could not reconstruct his competencies, and I have no idea how he would have performed in a 360-degree assessment. What I remember is the absence of doubt. We knew that when circumstances became uncomfortable, he would not suddenly redefine where his responsibility ended.

Modern organizations cannot recreate the conditions of a military unit, nor should they try. Corporate leadership operates within a complicated network of responsibilities, incentives, and legitimate competing interests. But organizations can ask whether the systems they have built to identify, develop, and reward successful executives leave enough room for those executives to exercise the kind of leadership they claim to value.

The tragedy is not that modern organizations are full of bad leaders. I do not believe they are. The tragedy is that they may be full of capable, decent people who entered leadership wanting to lead and discovered that succeeding required them to spend more and more of their time succeeding at everything else.

Thirty-seven years ago, a sergeant taught me something about leadership without ever teaching me leadership. He had authority because of the uniform and the rank on it, but that was not why we would have followed him beyond what the uniform required. We followed him because we knew that his responsibility for us did not disappear when exercising it became uncomfortable.

Perhaps organizations do not need another definition of leadership. Perhaps they need to give good people more opportunities to practice the one we already recognize when we see it.

Written by Mathias Goyen.
Have you read?
How to Stop Bringing Workplace Stress Home.
Seven Healthy Aging Habits for Busy Women.
Why Singapore and Ireland Are Reshaping Global Wealth Geography.
How NASCAR’s Richest Drivers Built Fortunes Beyond Racing.
Lula Wins Fourth Term as Brazil Delivers Divided Mandate.

Share this article:
Follow CEOWORLD Magazine on Google News

Follow CEOWORLD Magazine on: Google News, LinkedIn, X (Twitter), and Facebook.

Note: The views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of CEOWORLD Magazine, its Editorial Board, or management. Content is provided "as is," may contain monetized links, and is not professional advice. See our Ethics & Guidelines for details. Reproduction requires prior written permission.

Contact info@ceoworld.biz for inquiries or media requests.

Mathias Goyen, M.D.
Mathias Goyen, M.D., is Professor of Radiology and Chief Medical Officer at GE HealthCare. A physician, academic, and healthcare executive, he writes about technology, leadership,...

Read Mathias Goyen, M.D.’s full executive profile here →